On making peace with the life I didn’t get to live — and learning to love the one I have

by Tina Fey | September 18, 2025, 1:10 pm

I used to have a fantasy about my other life.

You know the one—the parallel universe version where I made different choices, took bigger risks, said yes when I said no and no when I said yes.

In that life, I was braver, wiser, more adventurous. I traveled more, loved more freely, spoke up more boldly.

In that life, I didn’t waste three years in the wrong relationship. I didn’t turn down opportunities because they felt too scary. I didn’t spend my twenties playing it safe instead of following dreams that seemed too big for someone like me.

For years, I carried this alternate version of myself like a secret. She was my measuring stick, my reminder of all the ways I’d fallen short. Every choice I’d made looked smaller next to the choices she would have made.

The cruel irony is that while I was busy mourning the life I didn’t live, I was barely present for the one I had.

I think most of us do this to some degree. We all have a story about who we could have been if only we’d been different, braver, luckier. We carry these phantom selves alongside our real ones, letting them cast shadows on our actual experiences.

But here’s what I’ve learned: making peace with the life you didn’t get to live isn’t about resignation or giving up on dreams.

It’s about something much more radical—learning to see the profound beauty and purpose in the life you actually chose, even when it doesn’t match the story you thought you were supposed to write.

The grief that nobody talks about

There’s a particular kind of loss that our culture doesn’t really acknowledge: the grief for the selves we never became.

We have rituals for death, divorce, job loss—all the concrete endings life hands us. But what about the mourning that happens when you realize you’re never going to be the person you thought you’d become by now?

What about the sadness that hits when you understand that certain doors have closed, not because of tragedy or external circumstances, but because of the thousand small choices that make up a life?

I remember the moment it really hit me. I was sitting in a coffee shop, watching a woman about my age laughing with friends, speaking what sounded like fluent Italian. She had this ease about her, this cosmopolitan confidence that I’d always imagined I’d develop someday.

Instead of admiring her or feeling curious, I felt a sharp pang of something I could only describe as homesickness—except I wasn’t homesick for a place.

I was homesick for a version of myself who spoke languages fluently, who moved through the world with that kind of easy sophistication.

The feeling caught me off guard because it wasn’t really about Italian or travel or even confidence. It was about all the ways I’d stayed small when I could have grown larger, all the times I’d chosen familiar over foreign, safe over sorry.

I spent years thinking this was productive. I called it “motivation” or “having high standards for myself.” But really, it was a subtle form of self-torture—holding my real life hostage to an imaginary one.

Recently, I’ve been reading Rudá Iandê’s new book Laughing in the Face of Chaos: A Politically Incorrect Shamanic Guide for Modern Life, and one passage stopped me cold:

“Our DNA is not a fixed blueprint to follow rigidly but a living code, inviting interpretation, expansion, and personal expression.”

That idea—that we’re not fixed, that our lives are still being written—offered a different way of thinking about all of this.

What if the life I didn’t live wasn’t evidence of failure, but simply one of many possible expressions of who I could be?

What if instead of grieving the paths not taken, I could honor them as part of the rich complexity of human possibility—and then turn my attention fully to the path I’m actually on?

The book inspired me to consider that maybe the issue wasn’t that I’d made wrong choices, but that I’d been evaluating my choices through someone else’s idea of what constitutes a life well-lived.

This grief for unlived lives often masks something deeper: the belief that there’s only one right way to be human, one optimal path through existence.

We compare our behind-the-scenes to everyone else’s highlight reel, not realizing that every life—even the ones that look effortlessly perfect from the outside—is full of roads not taken, dreams deferred, selves unexplored.

The woman speaking Italian in the coffee shop? She probably had her own phantom self—maybe someone who’d been braver in love, or who’d followed her art instead of her practical career, or who’d had children when she had the chance.

We all carry these ghosts, these might-have-beens. The question isn’t how to banish them, but how to live alongside them without letting them diminish the reality of what we’ve actually built.

The radical act of loving what is

Learning to love the life you have—really love it, not just tolerate it—requires a fundamental shift in how you define success, meaning, and even happiness itself.

It starts with recognizing that the life you’re living isn’t a consolation prize.

It’s not what you settled for when you couldn’t get what you really wanted.

It’s the actual result of your actual choices, made by your actual self, navigating your actual circumstances with your actual limitations and strengths.

And here’s the thing that took me years to understand: those limitations and circumstances weren’t obstacles preventing you from living your “real” life. They were the materials from which your real life was built.

The relationship that didn’t work out taught you what you actually needed in partnership.

The career path that felt too narrow forced you to develop skills and resilience you wouldn’t have discovered otherwise.

The moves you didn’t make, the risks you didn’t take—they weren’t failures of courage.

They were choices made by someone who knew things about their own life that their fantasy self never had to consider.

I think about this especially when I look at the choices I made in my thirties that my twenty-year-old self would have judged harshly.

I chose stability over adventure, security over uncertainty. Younger me would have seen this as giving up, playing it small, choosing fear over faith.

But she couldn’t have known about the deep satisfaction I’d find in building something sustainable, in creating a life with roots instead of wings.

She couldn’t have anticipated how much joy I’d discover in ordinary Tuesday mornings, in routines that once felt like prisons but now feel like home.

She couldn’t have known that sometimes the bravest thing isn’t leaving—it’s staying. Sometimes the most adventurous choice isn’t saying yes to everything—it’s saying no to almost everything so you can say a deeper yes to what matters most.

This doesn’t mean I’ve stopped growing or dreaming. It means I’ve stopped using my dreams as weapons against my reality.

There’s a difference between healthy aspiration and violent self-improvement—the kind that treats your current life as raw material to be transformed rather than as a living thing to be tended and appreciated.

The book reminded me that transformation doesn’t always look like dramatic reinvention. Sometimes it looks like recognition—seeing clearly what’s already there, what you’ve already built, who you’ve already become through the accumulation of choices both large and small.

I’ve started paying attention to the moments when I feel genuinely grateful for the life I have, not the life I think I should want.

These moments are quieter than the ones my fantasy self would have chosen, but they’re also deeper. More real. More mine.

Like the satisfaction of helping a client see their own strength clearly for the first time.

The way my body feels when I’m walking through my neighborhood at dusk, knowing I’m heading home to a space I’ve created with intention and care.

The conversations with friends who’ve seen me through multiple versions of myself and love all of them.

These aren’t the moments that make good social media posts or impressive dinner party stories. They’re not the stuff of other people’s fantasies.

But—they’re the foundation of a life that feels genuinely lived rather than performed.

Making peace with the life you have doesn’t mean giving up on change or growth. It means changing and growing from a place of abundance rather than scarcity, love rather than self-criticism, curiosity rather than shame.

It means understanding that your life—this one, the only one you’ll ever actually live—is not a rough draft of something better.

It’s the real thing, unfolding in real time, worthy of your full attention and appreciation right now.

The woman I might have been will always exist in the realm of possibility. But the woman I am exists here, in this body, in this moment, in this beautifully imperfect life that is nobody’s fantasy but mine to live.

And finally, I’m ready to live it.